Kicked It In the Sun    
  Trimmed and Burning    
  Stop the Show    
  You Were Right    
  Big Dipper    
  Fly Around My Pretty Little Miss    
  Three Years Ago Today    
  Cortez the Killer     [Neil Young]
  Someday*     [the Strokes]
second encore:
  Twin Falls    
  * First documented performance

With Porter Harp & Friends and Happy Stars.

The show was a benefit for Fantagraphix Inc. Thanks to Bill and Christopher for the information.